Who’s on First – Name a Better Skit

It’s probably the most recognized routine from the era. It’s the word play on words with double meanings. Costello is focused on interpreting the words in their strict usage in grammar, while Bud has changed their meanings as pronouns or phrases to be proper nouns as the names of the players. Though it ought to be an obvious miscommunication between the two, neither can remove his thought process outside his own definition of that word.

They had a similar routine using the old U-Drive company, later to become known as the Hertz Rental Car company. A name change that didn’t help out their act so much.

A lot more of their comedy centered on relationships from dating, to marriage, to divorce. Animals and kids were frequent themes, as when Bud and Lou went to the circus, or on a lion hunt.

Memorable moments on the radio include such things asJack Benny’s responce to getting robbed and confronted with the line, “Your money or your life!”

Catch phrases and signature lines like:
* Taint funny McGee,
* If I dood it I’ll get a whipping
*That ain’t the way I heared it
*Gildersleeves laugh,
* Jimmy Durant’s nose
* Fibber McGee’s closet
* Abner Peabody getting confused over Lum’s common figures of speech. (Old Eddards sayings)
* Fibber and Molly getting Mayor Latrivia flustered over his use of a harmless figure of speech.

Those character trademarks make for a flexible platform to set up any number of situations, using the same routine, but with any variety of variables to make the routine a little different every time. The same, but a little different, and when we begin to recognize the set up, we wait to see what new creation the characters will come up with this time.

We can always count on Crosby and Hope bickering like an old married couple. For that matter, the Bickersons bickering like an old married couple. Jack Benny created his stingy, insecure, childish, bossy persona over years to be a routine in itself that can be plugged into any setting to put his comic flavor in it.

Plenty of comedy formulas to be sure, but when it comes down to a complete comedy routine, that has stood the test of time, I think the “Who’s on First” routine is hard to beat. It’s one that can be easy to ad lib, the structure of the humor is there, and it’s always funny.

PS: This article is in response to a discussion on <a href=”http://otrcommunity.com”>OTR Community.</a> Visit the site, sign up, and get talking about OTR with other fans. Pop in to see how the rest of this conversation is going.


2 thoughts on “Who’s on First – Name a Better Skit”

  1. I saw this famous routine done on stage a couple of years ago at my local church concert. The two people concerned had spent a long time rehearsing it until they were word perfect, and the audience was rolling in the aisles. Timeless comedy.

    1. Lol. That sounds like a fun event.

      My personal first brush with Abbott and Costello came when I was in early grade school, maybe about age 9 or so. A local TV station aired old movies, and featured any number of old time greats. Including Abbott and Costello, Laurel and Hardy, Martin and Lewis, Hope and Crosby, and lots more.

      I probably saw their routine in one of those movies. I know they did it at the end of one of their films, I think it migh have been their first one. One Night in the Tropics (1940). The place I actually do remember hearing it came from my dad.

      We were at the Homecoming fair held in our town every Summer, and we started talking about the baseball team I played on that one and only year. He asked me if I knew the names of the players on my team. “Of course I do, I go to school with all of them.? Not taking that for my easy answer, he proceeded to pretend to guess names. He got a kick out of my confusion at his version of telling me that Who was on first, What’s on second and… you know the rest.

      I didn’t play along at first, thinking dad was just nuts. Who ever heard of a guy named Whoo? Then after giving me the hint that all I needed to do was follow his lead, and no matter what, keep misunderstanding about the ridiculous names, we had our own adlib going on. We had a great laugh over it, and as I recall we managed to adlib all the way up to “I Don’t Give a Darn!”

      After that, I made sure to pay attention when that Abbott and Costello movie came on TV. I rolled on the floor laughing when the masters pulled it off.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s